I had just bought a new mountain bike and really enjoyed my first few rides on some trails near my house. At first I couldn't be more pleased with it. The bike rode great and was a huge improvement over my old one. Unfortunately, I quickly noticed a problem when climbing up hills. After each pedal stroke I heard a rather loud and annoying "creak". I'm used to most normal bike noises, but this one had me worried.
Of course a "creak" is usually caused by two parts of the bike rubbing together under pressure. The real question (and not so simple one at that) is which two parts. I could simply ignore it, but that is almost certainly a bad idea. Creaks always seem to get worse over time and can end up in something breaking catastrophically. I can still remember when a "creaking" stem on my bike suddenly snapped into two pieces (an experience I don't recommend).
After several disappointing experiences with local bike mechanics, I had already decided I was going to
do all my own minor bike repairs. I was especially concerned about this particular problem because it only showed up while climbing steep hills. I couldn't make the problem happen on a bike repair stand or with the rear brake on. This meant that it wouldn't be easy for a bike mechanic to troubleshoot in their shop. I could easily see myself having to take the bike to the shop several times as they tried various "fixes". All the more reason to do it myself.
If you Google "bike", "creak" and similar terms you will find an overwhelming amount of information. Turns out "creaks" are a really common problem with multiple causes including:
- A cracked frame
- Bottom bracket shell / Bottom bracket bearing cups
- Chain ring bolts
- Crank arms / crank spindle
- Pedals / crank arms
- Rear wheel quick release too loose
- Spokes
- Seatpost / seat post clamp
- Saddle / saddle rails / saddle clamp
- Handlebar / Stem / Headset
- Loose rear cassette
Fixing this problem turned out to be a fun little project and I learned a tremendous amount at the same time. It also reinforced my belief that bikes really are precision machines that have quite a bit of impressive technology. However, with some patience, the right tools and healthy dose of curiosity even "non-experts" can fix them.
I'll go over the steps I took to diagnose my problem, how I eliminated the easy stuff, then what I did that eventually fixed the problem (hopefully) for good.
First up, how I started the troubleshooting.